GAME VS GAME

Pony Island vs Replica Player Count: Which Is More Popular?

Pony Island is more popular right now with 114 players on Steam, 38 times as many players as Replica (3). The highest all-time peak belongs to Pony Island (3,216 players).

Pony Island
114
playing now · 24h peak 176
Replica
3
playing now · 24h peak 3

Pony Island vs Replica player count chart

  • Pony Island
  • Replica

Concurrent players on Steam. Drag or pinch to zoom; the table below has every number.

Pony Island vs Replica: side by side

StatPony IslandReplica
Players right now1143
24-hour peak1763
All-time peak3,216Oct 10, 20266Oct 11, 2026
30-day average players464n/a
Steam reviews94.8% positive19k reviews85.8% positive3,437 reviews
Price now (US)$4.99$2.99
Lowest price we have seen$0.53 Dec 27, 2025$2.99 Oct 13, 2026
Twitch viewers now02 on average, 7 daysn/a
Release dateDec 1, 2015Jul 11, 2016

Green marks the leader in each row (for prices, the cheaper game). Prices are US Steam prices.

Add a game or change the comparison

Pony IslandReplica

Pick 2 to 4 games. Only games with a player count page can be compared.

Comparison FAQ

Which is more popular, Pony Island or Replica?

Pony Island is more popular right now with 114 players on Steam, 38 times as many players as Replica (3). The highest all-time peak belongs to Pony Island (3,216 players).

Which has the higher all-time peak on Steam, Pony Island or Replica?

Pony Island peaked at 3,216 concurrent players on October 10, 2026. Replica peaked at 6 concurrent players on October 11, 2026.

Is Pony Island or Replica cheaper on Steam?

Pony Island costs $4.99 on the US Steam store, and the lowest price we have seen is $0.53. Replica costs $2.99 on the US Steam store.

Player counts updated 20 minutes ago.

RageQuit Charts is not affiliated with Valve Corporation. Steam and the Steam logo are trademarks of Valve Corporation. Player counts come from the official Steam Web API.