A talking dog trots up to you outside Falkreath and asks you to mediate a fight with his owner. His owner is a Daedric Prince. Welcome to A Daedra’s Best Friend, the most wholesome way to get tangled up with Oblivion (yes, really).
I’m HairyGringo. Let me break this down for you: the full walkthrough, the one choice that actually matters, and why the Masque of Clavicus Vile beats the Rueful Axe by a mile.
Quest Overview
| Detail | What you need to know |
|---|---|
| Required level | 10 or higher |
| How it starts | A Falkreath guard mentions a stray dog, or you meet Barbas on the road outside town |
| Side job | Lod, the Falkreath blacksmith, wants that dog caught |
| Key locations | Falkreath, Haemar’s Shame, Rimerock Burrow |
| Daedric Prince | Clavicus Vile, Prince of wishes and bargains |
| Final choice | Kill Barbas for the Rueful Axe, or spare him for the Masque |
Lore Drop: Barbas isn’t really a dog. He’s Clavicus Vile’s companion and, in a sense, his conscience, a piece of the Prince split off into hound form. The Prince of bargains can’t keep his own dog on a leash, and the game plays that joke perfectly.
Step by Step Walkthrough
1. Take Lod’s job in Falkreath
At level 10 or above, a Falkreath guard asks if you’ve seen a stray dog and points you to Lod. Lod wants a strong dog caught near town. Take the job and he gives you meat for bait. You can also talk him into paying part of the reward up front, which costs you nothing.
2. Meet Barbas
Walk out on the road from Falkreath and a scruffy dog greets you like an old friend. Talk to him. He explains he’s had a falling out with his master and wants you to patch things up. Agree, and he leads you to Haemar’s Shame.
3. Clear Haemar’s Shame
Haemar’s Shame is a cave in the mountains east of Helgen, and it’s full of vampires. Bring fire. Vampires take extra fire damage, so flames, fire enchantments and fire arrows make this cave much easier.
Actually Do This: pack a Cure Disease potion. A vampire hit can give you Sanguinare Vampiris, and curing it within three days is a lot easier than a full cure quest later.
4. Talk to the statue
Deep in the cave is a shrine with a statue of Clavicus Vile. Speak to it. Vile agrees to take Barbas back, but only if you bring him the Rueful Axe from Rimerock Burrow.

5. Raid Rimerock Burrow
Rimerock Burrow is a small cave in the far northwest of Skyrim. Inside is Sebastian Lort, a Breton mage with a flame atronach on guard, so expect fire and summons. The axe lies on a table near an Arcane Enchanter, and a back room holds a chest of leveled loot. Grab both.
6. Make the choice
Go back to Haemar’s Shame. Vile now tries to talk you into killing Barbas with the axe, offering it as your reward. Or you can insist on handing the axe over and keeping the dog alive, in which case Vile gives you his Masque.
7. Collect from Lod
Either way, Barbas reunites with Vile, so you can tell Lod the dog is gone and collect the rest of your small payment. Don’t expect to retire on it.
Masque of Clavicus Vile vs. Rueful Axe
Actually, let’s look at the numbers.
| Reward | Type | Effects | Counts for Oblivion Walker? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Masque of Clavicus Vile | Helmet, base armor 23 | Speech +10, prices 20% better, Magicka regenerates 5% faster | Yes |
| Rueful Axe | Two-handed battleaxe, base damage 22 | Damages the target’s Stamina | No |

The Math: 20% better prices applies every single time you open a shop menu, for the rest of the game. Add the Speech boost, a little Magicka regeneration and credit toward the Oblivion Walker achievement (all fifteen Daedric artifacts), and the Masque wins easily.
Hot Take: killing a loyal dog for a stamina axe is the worst deal a Prince of bargains has ever offered. Spoiler: it’s not even close. If you want a heavy hitter, two-handed builds like the best beginner build have better options than this axe.
Plot twist: here the “good” ending is also the optimal one. That almost never happens with Daedric Princes.
Pro Tips
- Save before the second talk with Vile: The choice is permanent. A save lets you change your mind without redoing two caves.
- Fire for the vampires: Frost barely bothers them. Pyromancers will love this cave, and a Destruction heavy mage build clears it fast.
- Loot the back room: Rimerock’s chest is leveled, so it pays more the higher your level.
- Merchant players, wear it: Swap the Masque on before big sales. Thieves with a fence network will feel it most, and a stealth archer loots a lot.
- Want a dog buddy: Barbas follows you around while the quest is active, though once it’s done he goes home to Vile.
Every other artifact hunt and build lives on the Skyrim hub.
A Daedra’s Best Friend FAQ
What level do you need for A Daedra’s Best Friend?
Level 10. Before that, the Falkreath guard never brings up the stray dog.
Should you kill Barbas?
No. Sparing him gets you the Masque of Clavicus Vile, which is the stronger reward and the one that counts toward Oblivion Walker.
What does the Masque of Clavicus Vile do?
Speech +10, 20% better prices and 5% faster Magicka regeneration, on a helmet with 23 base armor.
Where is Rimerock Burrow?
In the far northwest of Skyrim. Vile marks it on your map when he asks for the Rueful Axe.
Actually Do This: Hit level 10, take Lod’s job, pack fire and a Cure Disease potion, and keep the dog alive. Then wear the Masque to your next shopping trip and watch the math pay you back.